top of page
The Lakehouse Bakery

What Goes Into a Lakehouse Thanksgiving Pie

Nov 12
3 min read

Caramelized pumpkin pie
Caramelized pumpkin pie

I love pie! Anyone who's ever talked to me has probably heard me say that. I love all kinds of pies and I take making them very serious. My favorite class to teach is Easy as Pie and it helps me on my mission to change how people make pie dough. I firmly believe there is a pie for every occasion and Thanksgiving is when pies really shine.


This is our eighth Thanksgiving. Last year we baked 550 pies for it. Every one of them was made from scratch, by hand, in our bakery on Sugarloaf Lake. Here is what goes into the pies on your table this year, and why they taste the way they do.


CARAMELIZED PUMPKIN: THE STEP NOBODY HAS TIME FOR

Back in September we told you that most canned pumpkin is not really what you picture as a pumpkin. What makes a pumpkin pie great is not the can, it is the cooking. We sauté our filling in a stock pot before it ever sees the rest of the custard ingredients. Cooking off the water concentrates the flavor and caramelizes the sugars, so you get a pie that tastes like deep and rich pumpkin instead of wet and spiced. It is a slow step, and it is the whole difference. We do it so you do not have to.


DUTCH APPLE: MICHIGAN APPLES, BUTTERY CRUMB

Michigan apple slices, sugar and spice tossed together then piled high and dotted with butter under a buttery crumb topping. Never tan goo from a bucket with soft apple bits and a chemical taste.


SOUTHERN PECAN: MOLASSES, HONEY AND REAL VANILLA

Our pecan pie is a molasses, local honey, brown sugar custard with local eggs and real vanilla bean paste loaded with pecans and baked until it is just set. Never any corn syrup.


THE CRUST UNDER ALL OF THEM

Every pie lives or dies by its crust. Ours is all butter, made with room temperature butter worked into the flour by hand. Measured, rolled and pressed into the tin, all by hand. No machines pressing and crimping it. It's the part people notice first. We par bake the crust for the pumpkin pie so the center bakes all the way through without burning the custard. Nothing is worse than a raw crust under your pie.


GLUTEN FREE, TOO

All three pies come in gluten free versions, so everyone at the table gets a slice. We use an Italian gluten free flour blend to make and roll the dough by hand. This is NOT your average frozen gluten free crust with ingredients you can't pronounce and made in a factory hundreds of miles away.


FOR THE REST OF THE TABLE

Dinner rolls, stuffing mix and our Olive Thyme bread, which we only bake in November. And if someone in your family insists on baking, our unbaked 8 oz butter pie dough ($3) and 9 inch gluten free crust ($8) give them a head start.


HOW TO ORDER

Orders close Friday, November 20. Pick up Wednesday, November 25 at the bakery or at one of our pickup spots, or we deliver free within 10 miles. Order online at thelakehousebakery.com/thanksgivingorder, call us at 734 306 3394, or stop in Tuesday through Saturday, 9 to 4, and we will fill out the form for you.


You handle the turkey. We have the pies.


Chef Keegan and The Lakehouse Bakery Team

Comments


bottom of page